AppsOverflow
AppsOverflowVideo to MP3 › Shortcut vs app

Video to MP3 with the iPhone Shortcuts App: Does It Work?

Updated 2026-07-11 · by AppsOverflow

Search “video to mp3 iphone” and you'll find people recommending the Shortcuts app. It's a real method and it's free — but it has one catch nobody mentions upfront: Shortcuts cannot produce an MP3 file. Its audio output is M4A.

Here's exactly how the shortcut works, when M4A is good enough, and when you'll want a real converter instead.

How to build the shortcut

  1. Create a new shortcut

    Open Shortcuts → + → add the action Encode Media.

  2. Set it to Audio Only

    Expand the Encode Media options and toggle Audio Only. Format will be M4A.

  3. Add “Save File”

    Append a Save File action so the result lands in Files. Optionally enable “Show in Share Sheet” so you can run it from any video.

Where the shortcut falls short

Shortcut vs converter app — honest comparison

If you need M4A once in a while and don't mind the one-time setup, the shortcut is genuinely fine — that's why we documented it here. Use it.

A converter app earns its place when you need true MP3 output, want to trim before saving, convert several files at once, or just don't want to maintain a DIY shortcut. Video to MP3 Converter does all of that on-device, with WAV and AAC as bonus formats.

Rule of thumb: M4A once a month → Shortcuts. Real MP3s, trims, or batches → use the app.
Video to MP3 Converter: Pro app icon
Video to MP3 Converter: ProFree to try · 4.6★ on the App Store
Skip the setup

FAQ

Can Shortcuts convert M4A to MP3 afterwards?
Not natively — Encode Media has no MP3 output. People chain web APIs into shortcuts to do it, but at that point your file is being uploaded to a third-party server anyway.
Is M4A worse quality than MP3?
No — at the same bitrate M4A (AAC) is actually slightly better. The issue is compatibility, not quality.